The “Religious Literacy Dictionary” in Stephen Prothero’s 2007 bestseller, Religious Literacy, devotes less than two pages to “Buddhism,” but spends seven lines making the point that “Buddhists have not been particularly active in American politics.” This notion, accurate or not, is probably the perception of most Americans, many of whom have little real awareness of the 2,500-year-old tradition to begin with. It may also explain why President Obama’s 25-member Advisory Council on Faith-based and Neighborhood Partnerships (which just launched its official Web site) currently lacks a Buddhist representative, despite the presence of at least one appointee from the other four major world religions.
That said, it bears mentioning that Buddhists have been conspicuously absent from many of the administration’s conversations about and efforts around religion in America. We were not included, for example, in President Obama’s inaugural address, which was addressed to “Christians, Jews, Muslims, Hindus, and non-believers.” In response, the noted scholar-practitioner Robert Thurman quipped at a City & Arts Lectures event in San Francisco that perhaps the Commander-in-Chief was including Buddhists, who don’t always fit into traditionally theistic models of religion, among the “non-believers.” This might be true, but I’d like to advance a case for including Buddhists more explicitly in the Oval Office’s work with religious organizations and services.
Admittedly, we Buddhists in America are few when compared with our sisters and brothers from, say, the Judeo-Christian religious traditions; the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life’s U.S. Religious Landscape Survey found that those who identify as Buddhist comprise 0.7% of the US population. Still, according to the think tank’s findings, of the five major world religions, Buddhism has the third largest following in the United States, with more adherents than Islam and Hinduism. In addition, Buddhist Americans comprise an incredibly unique and vibrant population—so much so that Los Angeles, for example, has become, as Harvard Divinity School’s Diana L. Eck has noted, “the most complex Buddhist city in the entire world.”
When you think about it, we have also left a remarkable legacy of offerings for our fellow Americans, both Buddhist and non-Buddhist. Consider, for example, the many temples and centers that serve as important hubs of religious education, spirituality, and community in and around large ethnic enclaves throughout the country, such as those under the purview of the Buddhist Churches of America or the Buddhist Council of New York. Consider Naropa University, the Institute of Buddhist Studies, University of the West, and Soka University of America—the four fully-accredited, Buddhist-affiliated, degree-granting institutions of higher education in the United States.
Consider the Insight Meditation Society, the San Francisco Zen Center, and Shambhala Mountain Center, each of which attract thousands of visitors every year for programs of contemplative practice and study. Consider Maitri Compassionate Care in San Francisco, a very early North American AIDS hospice established by the late Issan Dorsey of the Hartford Street Zen Center. Consider the Prison Dharma Network and the National Prison Hospice Association, both founded by Sensei Fleet Maull of the Zen Peacemaker Order.
Consider the Ikeda Center for Peace, Learning, and Dialogue at Cambridge, founded by Daisaku Ikeda, president of Soka Gakkai International. Consider the Bay Area-based Buddhist Peace Fellowship, which mobilizes dozens of chapters and thousands of members around important social and political issues. Consider publications like Tricycle: The Buddhist Review and Shambhala Sun (for whom I blog) that have found appeal beyond just their target demographic.
Consider the work of Buddhists in professional chaplaincy, which has been explored in recent articles in both the New York Times and Los Angeles Times. Consider the newly founded, New York-based Buddhist Global Relief, whose mission is to “provide relief to the poor and needy throughout the world regardless of nationality, ethnicity, gender, or religion.” These are but a very few examples of the incredible work of Buddhists in America. A Buddhist representative on the Council on Faith-based and Neighborhood Partnerships, then, seems quite appropriate, given that it is an initiative tasked with “[forming] partnerships… to more effectively serve Americans in need.”
It is worth mentioning too that Buddhist practices and ideas have begun to leave an indelible impression on the culture at large. Of special note, many non-Buddhist Americans have found the tradition’s teachings and tools helpful in their pursuit of better mental health. The historical Buddha, who abandoned a life of opulence and privilege in order that he might better understand the workings of his own mind and experience true spiritual awakening, once said simply, “I teach only suffering and the end of suffering.” So profound were his insights and those of his interlocutors throughout the ages, however, that modern psychologists and other caring professionals, particularly those in the United States, have found great utility in them. The emergence of such treatments as mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT), and dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), as well as further developments in other cognitive and behavioral therapies, owe much to Buddhist understanding. There is also a great deal of anecdotal evidence to support claims about the growing influence of the tradition in caregiving and counseling generally. I find it telling, for example, that HBO, as part of a recent documentary produced to promote their psychotherapy-centered series In Treatment, made it a point to include Buddhist psychologist Mark Epstein alongside notable Freudians, Jungians, and others representing more traditional schools of thought in the field.
Tags: buddhism, council for faith-based and neighborhood partnerships, obama administration, pluralism, shambhala sun, tricycle
Danny, thanks for the excellent article. I have also wondered about the same thing, especially in light of the Buddhist contributions to the UN's International Decade for a Culture of Peace and Non-violence, though it goes without saying that we really haven't done our part when it comes to neighborhood partnerships.
A perfect example is that "most complex Buddhist city in the entire world,” as Diana L. Eck refers to Los Angeles... although the temples and welfare societies of Little Tokyo and Chinatown sit in the shadows of Skid Row in downtown LA, there has been very little involvement, long enough inter-action with other groups in providing outreach and social services, so maybe participation in the Advisory Council would also serve as a catalyst in this regard.
excellent piece, Danny, I have wondered about this, too. Buddhists being left out does point at a theological issue--that this may be more about gathering theists than religious folks. Or simply that Asian Americans are still given short shrift by the government. Buddhism and Buddhist identity in America, in relation to other faiths and society as a whole, is only getting more complicated.
There are Buddhists in Washington, including elected ones. But no one gets ahead in Washington by admitting he's a Buddhist.
Most Buddhists are not concerned with politics. It's better to ignore politics.
"Politics, as a practice, whatever its professions, has always been the systematic organization of hatreds." ~ Henry B. Adams
Buddhism is NOT the third largest religion in the USA. Get your facts straight.
Enhanced Kre-Alkalyn
Comments closed
The comments for this story have been closed. Thank you to everyone who participated.