Is Liberal Zionism Dead?

That’s a question that has been discussed quite a bit lately, as liberal Zionists raise red flags about right-ward, anti-democratic trends in Israel, as well as Operation Protective Edge. In a bloggingheads episode during which we also discussed my piece here, “The Collapse of the American Jewish Center,” political scientist Brent Sasley and I debated the liberal Zionist crisis.

You can watch the whole episode here.

Sarah Posner, author of God’s Profits: Faith, Fraud, and the Republican Crusade for Values Voters, covers politics and religion. Her work has appeared in The Washington Post, The Guardian, The Atlantic, The American ProspectThe NationSalon, and other publications. Follow her on TwitterRSS feed Email

  • Jim Reed

    I think you are asking the wrong question. The question should be,
    Is conservative (fill in the blank) falling off the deep end?

  • Jim Reed

    I don’t think you have told us where you come down on all these. J street? If not now? Spiritual but not religious? Or do you not like to comment for the sake of journalism?

  • S N Smith

    Liberal zionism is still zionism and it needs to go

  • Husband of the Moonlight

    “Liberal Zionist” is simply an ‘oxymoron’ ; a true Liberal could never be anything but an Atheist—or to be more precise a “non-theist”. Being a “believer” in ANY DEITY OR RELIGION REQUIRES THE BELIVER TO BECOME A SLAVE TO “FAITH” WHICH IS NOTHING MORE THAN FICTION AND IMAGINATION.
    “Faith is believing in something you doesn’t exist” Mark Twain

  • http://wonderwheels.blogspot.com/ Gregory Wonderwheel

    ‘Husband’, you took the words out of my fingers, at least your first phrase did. I would add it is the oxymoron of the worst kind because it is a self-delusion that one puts on oneself like the Emperor’s New Clothes. Since Zionism requires a racist perspective of race superiority and exclusive control of geography in the name of race, that project can never be a liberal project because equality of people regardless of race is a non-negotiable feature of a liberal perspective.
    However, I don’t agree with the assessment that being a believer in any religion makes it impossible to be a liberal or even better yet a progressive. That assertion is an example of category confusion. A person can be a liberal or conservative on the political dimension regardless of their position on the religious dimension as an atheist, non-theist, pantheist, panentheist, monotheist, polytheist, etc. I’m Buddhist and I recognize there are conservative rightwing Buddhists as well as my kind of radical progressive Buddhists. There are wackadoo right wingnut conservative non-theists as well as liberal non-theists.

  • Aravis Tarkheena

    Explain that to the millions of Reform Jews.