“What Kind of Islam Is That?”: Talking With Refugees From ISIS

The author speaking with Yazidi women refugees from Sinjar, Iraq, in a refugee camp near Diyarbakir, Turkey in July, 2015.

“They believe in some strange religion, not Islam,” a Muslim refugee from the Iraq city of Ramadi told me when I talked with him recently in a camp near the Kurdistan capital of Erbil in Northern Iraq. ISIS territory was some 40 miles away, but he spoke as if they could return at any moment.

“They reject our religion and say we are not sufficiently Muslim, but they kill the men and rape the women. What kind of Islam is that?”

arabrefugee

Though his religious affiliation was Sunni Muslim and his ethnic identity was Arab—the kind of people that ISIS regards as its preferred community—he had been a policeman in Ramadi and knew that he would be targeted. His neighbors were frightened as well, having heard stories about the harsh rule of the ISIS commanders and the loss of freedom under their control. As soon as he heard fighting at the edge of town he and other families quickly climbed into their cars at two o’clock in the morning and escaped. Most of the rest of the city joined them, he said. Now they are waiting in the camp, hoping for ISIS to leave the town so they can return.

It was a story repeated by dozens of refugees that I met this summer in refugee camps and makeshift shelters in Kurdistan and southeastern Turkey. They seemed puzzled about who ISIS was and what they wanted.

Most used the term “Daesh” for ISIS, based on an acronym for the Arabic name for the movement, al-Dawla al-Islamiya al-Iraq al-Sham (“the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant [wider Syria]”–ISIL or ISIS). By coincidence, the term daesh also means something like the Arabic word for “bullies,” and for that reason ISIS leaders are annoyed by its usage. Probably also for that reason the term persists among those victimized by it.

“The Daesh leaders are foreigners,” a Kurdish man from a village near Mosul told me, saying he didn’t know where they came from, since he didn’t recognize their form of Arabic. The local members of the movement, he said, were poor people forced into it, though some seemed to be true believers.

An automobile dealer from a village north of Mosul recognized one of the ISIS fighters who captured him as a man in the village to whom he had sold a car. The car dealer was from the Kurdish ethnic community; the man who bought his car was an Arab.

When the town was surrounded by ISIS, the militants forcibly divided the population into its Kurdish and Arab groups. One of the Arabs suggested that representatives from both groups wave a white flag and go to the ISIS leaders to negotiate their way out of the situation. That’s when the car dealer recognized his former customer among the ISIS fighters. The customer-turned-ISIS-fighter looked down and tried to avert the gaze from his former neighbor.

The negotiations soon broke down and the Arabs were told that they would not be harmed as long as they did nothing to impede ISIS’ authority and if some of the men would volunteer to fight on their side. The Kurds were not given any assurances, and fearing the worst most of them slipped away that night in the darkness to safety. They heard that those who stayed were divided into men and women’s groups. The men were killed and the women were taken into slavery.

Is It About Religion? Or About Power?

I talked with another fellow, a Syrian Christian pharmacist who had in fact stayed in his Syrian village after it had been taken over by ISIS forces. When he became a refugee he was able to stay in a slightly more comfortable Christian camp than the one for Arab Muslims; it was set up in what had formerly been a playground next to a Catholic church in the Erbil suburb of Ankawa. The camp consisted of one-room campers instead of tents, supplied by the Christian charity, the Good Samaritans.

The pharmacist told us that the Syrian Army had assured them that they would be safe as ISIS approached. But then the army suddenly disappeared, and ISIS had taken the town. At first, the ISIS militants told them they would not be harmed as long as they gave them all their money and their cell phones. In other villages, they heard, an agreement to convert to Islam and a payment of $7 per month would allow them to survive. But initially they were not given those options.

Moreover, his wife was taunted for wearing a Western-style dress, as many Christian women do, so she could not venture outside. They also kept their daughters hidden, fearing they would be captured by ISIS and sold into sex slavery.

They waited until the middle of the night and then they and their neighbors made a break for freedom. They piled into the back of trucks and with the lights out drove madly through checkpoints and down the road towards Iraq and Kurdistan. The pharmacist showed me a video he had made with his cell phone, which did indeed look like a cattle surge of vehicles illumined by a few eerie lights. Now the news from his town is “very bad”—there is no water or electricity or food in stores.

Christians are forced to make payments to be allowed to survive and have to pretend to be Muslims and go to the mosque, and ISIS militants roam around the streets and do whatever they want.

When I asked several of the refugees whether ISIS was motivated by religion or by power, they said “power,” but that they used religion as an excuse for their authority. One Kurdish man from the Syrian town of Dierzor said that he had evidence that the ISIS fighters weren’t really religious.

The Kurd told a story that he had heard about a Christian Syrian who was arrested by an ISIS soldier at check point. The ISIS soldier asked the Christian to state his religion. “Muslim,” the Christian said, trying to save himself. The ISIS fighter then asked the Christian to prove it by reciting the Qur’an. The Christian mumbled some verses from the Bible, the only scripture he knew. “Good enough,” said the ISIS militant, unaware that the verses were not Qur’anic, and let him through unharmed.

When I asked the Kurd what kind of people supported ISIS in his home town of Dierzor, he said only a few did; they were mostly poor people who received money if they joined the movement as fighters. ISIS, he said, pays their soldiers 1000 dollars a month, whereas the Syrian opposition groups pay only $500. And ISIS does pay in US dollars, interestingly, perhaps from money it receives from illicit oil sales.

The Kurd said that all of his Kurdish neighbors in Dierzor were gone. They were told by ISIS they could stay but then killing began. Now all Kurds have either escaped and are refugees, or have been killed.

My hosts in Erbil had found this fellow, the Syrian Kurd, encamped in a vacant lot, where they took me to meet him. Though most of the two million refugees in Kurdistan—a fourth of the population of the region—were in orderly refugee camps living in tent cities or in clusters of pre-fab modular rooms, some, like him, had taken refuge in empty lots or unfinished buildings in the city of Erbil. Since the rise of ISIS has brought Erbil’s economic boom to a halt and stalled its construction frenzy, there are plenty of abandoned buildings to serve as shelters.

In the case of the Syrian Kurd with whom I spoke, he and his family along with three other families had created a tent city on an unused site at a street crossing. They poured concrete slabs and illegally tapped into an adjacent power line for electricity. They dug into the ground and connected to the city’s water supply to have drinking water and dug a pit for a latrine. With television and a refrigerator, they managed to create a viable living space.

The residents of Erbil were remarkably tolerant—sympathetic, really—to the situation of such impromptu refugee camps, and the refugees in vacant lots received hand-outs and help from the neighbors. The government of Kurdistan, however, is trying to encourage all refugees to live in camps, and are rapidly building more to house them. But new refugees continue to pour in.

Many of the approved camps consisted of rows of modular houses, or tent roofs over one-room buildings with cinder block walls. Many had water, electricity and toilets in each unit, with solar-powered satellite dishes for TV. In other cases, each family had only a tent and shared rows of common toilets with hundreds of other families. The canvas roofs bore the insignia of the United Nations, though private relief organizations, including many from Kurdistan itself, were donors as well. Though most refugees came when ISIS overran the region two years ago, some were war-weary Syrians who had been nomads for years. A few were new arrivals.

One of the newest refugees I talked with was the young Sunni Arab man and his family who had just arrived from the town of Ramadi, west of Baghdad, that fell to ISIS forces in May, 2015. He said that he and 90% of the population left on one side of the town as ISIS entered the other. There had been heavy fighting, he said, and his own nine-month daughter had been killed in the fighting. And then the Iraqi Army just gave up and left. The townspeople panicked. They drove their cars into the desert, and then to Baghdad, but were turned away in Baghdad because they were Sunni and Baghdad was controlled by Shi’a militia. For that reason they came back to the desert, and a few, such his family and himself, were able to fly to Erbil to stay in safer refugee camps.

The Ramadi man had heard reports that ISIS had set up a check point at the entrance to the town next to an open pit that served as a mass grave. When people tried to enter the city, the ISIS guards checked their computers to see if they could pass through, and if not they shot them on the spot and tossed their bodies into the open grave.

Neither Muslim nor Arab: the Plight of Yazidi Refugees

In Southeastern Turkey there are additional refugee camps for Kurds, including those Kurds who worship the ancient Yazidi religion. I went to the Kurdish city of Diyarbakir to visit a Yazidi camp where some 3500 were living in tents in what had been a municipal park. I had to get special permission as a writer from government authorities to enter any refugee camp in Kurdistan or Turkey—though in this case I also had to gain the approval of local leaders who ran the camp. One of them joined in the conversations and urged the Yazidi refugees to tell me what had happened to them. Their stories were particularly harrowing.

A middle-aged Yazidi woman from the town of Sinjar told me her story about how they waited too long to make their escape. She said that initially the Kurdish troops, the Peshmurga, assured them that they would be safe, and not to worry. When they heard that a nearby city, Tel Afar, had fallen to ISIS, they still stayed. The Peshmurga troops, however, were overrun and ISIS took control.

She knew that the Yazidi people would be targeted by ISIS since they were not Muslim. She had heard that they were killing Christians for not being Muslim, and Sunni Muslim Kurds for not being Arabs, so she knew that her people would be doubly damned since their religion was Yazidi and their ethnic community was Kurdish. The woman said that she and other Yazidis rushed through the main street and many of the men were killed, including her husband and his brothers, but she and her children kept going to safety. They fled to the Sinjar mountains along with thousands of other Yazidi refugees. After many days, she said, the Kurdish militant movement, the PKK, opened a corridor of safety for them to escape.

She has heard reports that teenage girls were taken to warehouses where they were auctioned off to “old men” who bought them as sex slaves. Some were bought for no more than a thousand Iraqi dinars, which amounts to less than a US dollar.

I asked her and several of the other refugees in her camp and in Erbil whether they thought that ISIS would stay in power long. Yes, they sadly affirmed, since “they were evil,” as one of them put it: they knew how to intimidate people through killing. At the same time they knew there was little future for them as refugees in Kurdistan or Turkey. They had no option but to hope that they could return to their villages and towns.

“All we have left is hope,” one of the men said.

__________________

My thanks to those who helped with arrangements and translation while I was in Kurdistan, Iraq, and Southeast Turkey in July, 2015, including Ibrahim Barlas of the Pacifica Institute; Ibrahim Anli of the Journalists and Writers Foundation in Istanbul; Ardalan Jalal of Erbil’s Dialogue Middle East; and Hasan Yilmaz of the Diyarbakir Entrepreneurs and Businesspeople’s Association.

 

 

9 Comments

  • What does one say to such horrors? We can offer help and we can offer compassion to these refugees, but until we stop saying that ISIS is a religious movement and start facing the fact that they are political, power-mad lunatics with no religious justification for their actions, we will never stop them or their horrors.

    ISIS is NOT ISLAM!

    It is politics and murder and destruction by a bunch of ignorant lunatics who saw an opportunity, with support from Saudi Arabia, to take over land, oil, and people where people did not follow the same religion some of them did. We see less violent forms of this kind of religious tyranny right here in the US by people claiming to Christians who would deny others their religious beliefs because they do not follow the same form of Christianity. Recently I saw an episode of Marriage Boot Camp, where one of the wives said that she and her husband had different faiths: She was Christian and he was Catholic. The person overseeing this dialogue was stunned to say the least and pointed out that they were both Christians, just different denominations. The wife just shook her head in disagreement. It is the same with the Shiites and the Sunnis – same religion just different denominations. The kind of religious bigotry we see today here in the US is rapidly devolving into the kind of religious zealotry we see in the Middle East, and it is just as dangerous.

    I live in a community dominated by Pentecostal/Evangelical/Apostolic Christians who have driven underground or out of town anyone who does not agree with their guns, God, and Armageddon beliefs. They can be dangerous, and if you challenge their beliefs by actually pointing out that Jesus never taught homophobia or religious intolerance or that he was Jewish his whole life, you risk possible physical injury and property damage as a result. The town is dying because they insist on following the money to rich hay farmers who control the economy here, and refuse to allow more advanced technologies or businesses to come into town, forget an interfaith church for those who do not want to attend their churches. They drive out their young people and make newcomers so unwelcome that they leave within three years, unless they become part of the religious flocks that follow blindly the ravings of their ministers. I see first hand where people like Kim Davis and her religious freedom ideas lead, and it is not one bit different from what ISIS is doing in the communities where it has invaded. The only difference here is that in the US we give up our rights and freedoms without guns and violence, we do it on our knees in radicalized Christian churches filled with homophobes and racists and religious intolerance. Soon though I fear, such quiet compliance is not going to be enough, and they will put down their Bibles and take up their guns to save those of us who do not give up to them, and then civil war will start just as it did for ISIS.

  • elvenforest9@yahoo.com' Serai says:

    I would also add that the term ISIS should be abolished. It’s IS or ISIL, please. Isis was/is an amazingly beautiful cultural construct and a symbol of strength and power for women. It’s one of the filthiest crimes these creatures have committed, that they’ve basically allied that name with their slimy, evil garbage. Let’s not play their game, shall we?

  • abdula89@gmail.com' Nation State says:

    Rofl the tax is 7$ and this is one of the sticking issues with Christians attempting to prove the archaic nature of Islamic govt. I probably pay more than 7$ flushing my piss away monthly. Jizya, Poll tax, Dhimmi, its all the same thing.

  • brucedunn88@yahoo.com' MrBiggsEsq says:

    I just don’t understand this disconnect people see between the IS and violence! There are plenty of examples of Mohammed (personally) and his closest followers raping, kidnapping, ransoming, and murdering people in the Koran and the Ahadith who didn’t submit to their (then) new movement….. Case closed…

  • sharialaw101@gmail.com' TruthNeedsFreedom says:

    And yet the ISIS people will insist that they are true Islam and that it is the other Muslims that are not. And they publish a long list of reasons to validate their own point of view.
    Almost all of the ISIS followers/leaders are “radicalized”. What does that term imply other than that they have intently studied the religion and have pledge to live it “devoutly”.
    Yet most fascinating is the communications and fatwa’s that come forth from the ISIS imam’s and other leaders that cite verses of the Quran and ancient traditions of Mohammed to justify their actions.

  • jmw111085@hotmail.com' jimbo says:

    Jurgensmeyer quotes a refugee who says, “They kill the men and rape the women” then asks, “What kind of religion is that?” The answer is Islam.

    Most of what ISIS does is the same thing Muhammad did. Did Muhammad kill non-Muslims? Yes. Did Muhammad and the subsequent Caliphs kill Muslims they considered apostates? Yes. Did Muhammad allow the rape of female prisoners? Yes.

    Renan said that the Muslims are the first victims of Islam. Certainly in Jurgensmeyer’s study
    they are. These poor Muslims, and others, are feeling the teeth of Islam.

    Jurgensmeyer asks, “Is it about religion? Or about power?” Again someone familiar with Islam would know the answer: “Both.” Islam is a religion of power.

    Muhammad committed many barbaric acts so why is it wrong for Muslims today to do what he did and commanded?

    Surely Jurgensmeyer is capable of doing some actual study and seeing the connections between Muhammad’s teachings and actions, and what ISIS is doing. They have far more in common than not.

  • s.d.stewart@gmail.com' Sam says:

    When I asked several of the refugees whether ISIS was motivated by religion or by power, they said “power,” but that they used religion as an excuse for their authority. One Kurdish man from the Syrian town of Dierzor said that he had evidence that the ISIS fighters weren’t really religious.

    The Kurd told a story that he had heard about a Christian Syrian who was arrested by an ISIS soldier at check point. The ISIS soldier asked the Christian to state his religion. “Muslim,” the Christian said, trying to save himself. The ISIS fighter then asked the Christian to prove it by reciting the Qur’an. The Christian mumbled some verses from the Bible, the only scripture he knew. “Good enough,” said the ISIS militant, unaware that the verses were not Qur’anic, and let him through unharmed.

    When I asked the Kurd what kind of people supported ISIS in his home town of Dierzor, he said only a few did; they were mostly poor people who received money if they joined the movement as fighters. ISIS, he said, pays their soldiers 1000 dollars a month, whereas the Syrian opposition groups pay only $500. And ISIS does pay in US dollars, interestingly, perhaps from money it receives from illicit oil sales.

  • emilyk04@gmail.com' Fired, Aren't I says:

    “Daesh,” The Arabic acronym, and the word that also is a double entendre that means “bully.”

  • elvenforest9@yahoo.com' Serai says:

    Yeah, trying to get Americans to use an Arabic word instead of a convenient acronym will be tricky at best.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *